If you've spent any time reading home barista forums, you've seen both of these names come up constantly usually in the same sentence, sometimes with someone confidently telling you that you bought the "wrong" one. Don't worry, there's no wrong choice here, just a right one for your setup. Let's sort out who each grinder is actually for, and why the $50 gap between them isn't arbitrary.
The Short Version
- Buy the Baratza Encore ($149.95) if you brew drip, pour-over, French press, or Aeropress — basically anything that isn't espresso.
- Buy the Baratza Encore ESP ($199.99) if espresso is in the picture at all, even occasionally.
That covers most of the decision. The rest of this comes down to why, because understanding the mechanical difference will actually help you use whichever grinder you end up with.
At a Glance
| Baratza Encore | Baratza Encore ESP | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $149.95 | $199.99 |
| Best for | Drip, pour-over, French press, Aeropress | Espresso, plus everything else |
| Grind range | Coarse to medium-fine | Espresso-fine to coarse |
| Espresso-capable | No | Yes |
| Adjustment | 40 click-stop settings | Click-stop, wider range, first 20 settings dedicated to espresso micro-adjustments |
| Motor / build | High-torque DC motor, ~450 RPM | Same motor and build as standard Encore |
Same motor and build quality on both — the difference is entirely in the burr set and grind range, not in durability or core construction.
Why the Grind Range Is the Whole Story
Espresso needs an unusually fine, unusually consistent grind much finer than pour-over, and with far less tolerance for inconsistent particle size. That fine grind is what builds the resistance the espresso machine's pump pushes water against; too coarse, and the shot runs too fast and tastes thin and sour. Too fine, and it chokes the machine or turns bitter.
The original Encore's burr set is tuned for the coarser end of that spectrum — great for drip, pour-over, French press but it physically cannot get fine and consistent enough for good espresso. This isn't a software limitation or a "cheaping out" issue; the burrs themselves are shaped and spaced differently. Baratza built the Encore ESP with a separate burr set specifically engineered to reach espresso-fine grinds while still covering the coarser settings other brew methods need.
So if you already own the standard Encore and you're happy brewing pour-over or drip, there's no reason to upgrade it's not "worse" for what it does, it's simply not built to do espresso. Buying the ESP version wouldn't make your pour-over any better; it would just add a range you don't use.
Where the Encore ESP Pro Fits In
If you're weighing this against our Baratza Encore ESP Pro ($299.95) as well, that's the stepless version of the ESP — same espresso-capable burr range, but with infinitely fine adjustment instead of click-stops.
Click-stops (what the standard ESP uses) are fine for most people: you find a setting that works, you leave it there, you adjust in whole-step increments if your shots start running fast or slow. Stepless adjustment matters more once you're actively fine-tuning shots day to day — chasing a slightly faster or slower extraction as beans age, humidity changes, or you switch roasts. If that sounds like more precision than you'll actually use, the standard ESP is the better value; the Pro is for people who already know they'll use the extra control.
The Encore, in More Detail
If you're leaning toward the standard Encore, here's what you're actually getting for $149.95:
- Burrs: 40mm conical steel burrs, manufactured in Europe, with a grind range of roughly 250–1200 microns
- Settings: 40 stepped grind settings, adjusted by simply turning the bean hopper
- Motor: High-torque DC motor spinning at a low ~450 RPM, which keeps the grind cool and the grinder quiet — a typical espresso-weight dose takes about 7 seconds to grind
- Capacity: 8oz bean hopper, 5oz removable, anti-static grounds bin
- Size and weight: Just under 14" tall, about 7 lbs, sized to fit under most kitchen cabinets
- Controls: A simple on/off switch plus a front-mounted pulse button for topping off a dose
- Protection: A thermal overload cutoff that protects the motor if it's run too long in one go — a reasonable safeguard, since these grinders are built for single-dose home grinding rather than continuous commercial use
One thing worth flagging honestly: you'll see some listings market the standard Encore as espresso-capable, since its finest setting can technically grind fine enough for a stovetop moka pot or a very forgiving pressurized machine. In practice, though, dialing in consistent, repeatable espresso shots is exactly what Baratza redesigned the ESP's burr set to handle the Encore ESP dedicates its first 20 settings entirely to micro-adjustments within the espresso range, while the standard Encore spreads its 40 settings across a much wider span built for drip, pour-over, and French press. If espresso is a serious, regular part of your routine rather than an occasional experiment, that's the practical reason to spend the extra $50.
Which One Actually Fits Your Setup
Go with the standard Encore if:
- You brew pour-over, drip, French press, or Aeropress
- You don't own an espresso machine and don't plan to buy one soon
- You want an easy, affordable way into a real burr grinder that will last for years — it's a genuinely great first upgrade from a blade grinder, and a lot of home brewers start right here
Go with the Encore ESP if:
- You own or are buying an espresso machine — check out the Breville Bambino or Lelit Anna if you're still shopping for one
- You want one grinder that can flex between espresso and other brew methods, since it covers both ranges
- You're willing to pay $50 more for that wider range, even if you only use the fine end occasionally
Go with the Encore ESP Pro if:
- Espresso is a daily habit, not an occasional one
- You want to fine-tune extraction rather than pick a setting once and leave it
- You've already outgrown click-stop adjustment on another grinder and know what you're looking for
What They Have in Common
All three share the same reliable motor and overall build quality Baratza is known for this isn't a case of the cheaper option being flimsy. The differences are entirely in the burr set and adjustment mechanism, not in longevity or core construction. All three are also simple to maintain: for a refresher on keeping any grinder running well, our equipment cleaning guide covers it, and burr grinders specifically benefit from a quick brush-out every couple of weeks if you're grinding daily.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the standard Encore grind fine enough for Aeropress? Yes Aeropress uses a mid-range grind, well within the standard Encore's capability. It's really only true espresso that requires the ESP's burr set.
Will the ESP grinder ruin my pour-over if I use it for both? No the ESP covers the same coarser range the standard Encore does, plus the finer espresso range. You lose nothing by choosing the ESP if you brew multiple methods; you just pay a bit more for the flexibility.
Is the price difference just branding? No it reflects an actual different burr set manufactured for a different grind range, not a marketing tier on identical hardware.
There's no wrong grinder here just a mismatched one. Buy for the brew method you actually use most, not the one you might use someday, and enjoy the upgrade either way. Fresh, evenly ground coffee makes a bigger difference than most people expect.
Every purchase gives back — see how we support youth education and nature conservation.
